Newsroom

Newsroom image of kids

Child Watch® Column: "See Something, Say Something"

Release Date: June 29, 2012

Marian Wright Edelman

On June 25th, the U.S. Supreme Court in Miller v. Alabama banned mandatory sentences of life in prison without parole for juveniles. This is a major victory for children and for America and a giant step forward for justice for children. Until this week, America was the only country in the world to routinely condemn children as young as 13 and 14 to die in prison. Now about two thousand people who were sentenced to die in prison as juveniles have hope for a new hearing and a new sentence. While we are disappointed the Court did not ban the practice outright, we must keep working toward justice for children and end the devastating Cradle to Prison Pipeline™ crisis that leads to marginalized lives, imprisonment, and premature death.

Bryan Stevenson, the brilliant Founder and Executive Director of Equal Justice Initiative in Montgomery, Alabama, argued this case and the companion case Jackson v. Hobbs before the Supreme Court. Earlier in June he told participants at the Children’s Defense Fund Freedom Schools® National Training session how he first became devoted to helping children in our adult justice system:

“I was working on a case when a grandmother called me, and this young boy had been arrested. This boy was living in a house where his mother had repeatedly been the victim of a lot of sexual assault, a lot of physical assault and domestic violence. And one day this boy's stepfather came home, and he just punched this boy's mother in the face. She fell on the floor unconscious, and the little boy tried to revive his mom and he couldn't do it, and she was bleeding. And we think he thought his mom was dead.”

Bryan Stevenson continued with his harrowing true crime story: “And the man went into the bedroom and fell asleep, and after he did that, this little boy got up. He was about five feet tall, 14 years of age, under 100 pounds, and he waited until the man went into the bedroom and fell asleep . . . and he went over to the man's dresser, and he pulled out this man's handgun. And while the man was sleeping, this little boy walked over to him, and he pointed the gun at his head, and tragically at point-blank range, he pulled the trigger. The man was killed instantly.

“Now, this child had no prior criminal history. He had never been in trouble before. He was actually a good student, no juvenile adjudications, and probably would have been tried as a juvenile but for the fact that this man was a deputy sheriff. And because he was a deputy sheriff, the prosecutor insisted that this child be tried as an adult, and the judge certified him to stand trial as an adult and put him in the adult jail.

“The grandmother called me three days later, and I went to the jail to see this little boy. I started asking him questions, and no matter what I asked him, this little boy just sat there. I tried to ask him some more questions; he just sat there. He wasn't responding to anything I said, and finally after 20 minutes, I said, ‘Look, you got to talk to me. I can't help you if you don't talk to me.’

“I got up and I walked around the table, and I got my chair close to him . . . I started leaning on him a little bit and leaning on him, and finally, he leaned back. And when he leaned back into me, I put my arm around him and said, ‘Come on, tell me what's going on.’ This boy started crying, and through his tears, he began talking to me not about what happened at his house with his mom or his stepdad, but he began talking to me about what had happened at the jail. He told me on the first night, he had been assaulted by several men. Then he told me on the next night, he had been sexually assaulted by several men, and then he told me on the night before I had gotten there, there were so many people who had assaulted him, he actually couldn't remember how many there had been.

“I held this little boy while he cried hysterically for over an hour, and I left that jail thinking this is our system—our system—and so it became necessary for me to say something.”

So now, Bryan Stevenson said, “I represent these young people who have many times been horribly abused. We put them in adult prisons. There are 27 states that put children in adult facilities where they are 10 times more likely to be the victims of sexual assault, 25 times more likely to commit suicide, and there is this silence.” Once he saw the truth, he knew he could never be among those who stay silent. He also said: “Of all the problems that I'm talking about [with the treatment of juveniles in the adult justice system]—and I'm talking about race and I'm talking about poverty and I'm talking about abuse of power and I'm talking about misconduct—the problem that we have got to confront is hopelessness, the profound absence of hope that is represented by the death penalty, by life imprisonment without parole for children, by mass incarceration, by the way in which we are dealing with people . . . I'll tell you something about hope. Where there is hopelessness, there is always injustice, and you can never achieve justice without hopefulness.”

The Supreme Court’s historic decision to abolish mandatory life in prison without parole sentences for children reinforces the importance of never giving up hope as we all keep speaking out and fighting for justice for children. We still have so much work left to do to solve the crisis of children in adult prisons--but we now have a huge victory to spur us on and give us more hope. Bryan Stevenson helped changed the nation’s course by saying something and doing something, and so must we.


Marian Wright Edelman is President of the Children's Defense Fund whose Leave No Child Behind® mission is to ensure every child a Healthy Start, a Head Start, a Fair Start, a Safe Start and a Moral Start in life and successful passage to adulthood with the help of caring families and communities. For more information go to www.childrensdefense.org.

Mrs. Edelman's Child Watch Column also appears each week on The Huffington Post.

Sign-up to receive CDF President Marian Wright Edelman's weekly Child Watch Column.

 

Let us know what you think about this column:

Nickname
Comment
Enter this word: Change

 

Here's what others have said:

Submitted by Gale at: July 1, 2012
How was this child convicted? Did he not have an attorney to defend him and argue he was the victim of PTSD? And where was the system and grandmother when he needed rescuing from the home? No child should endure what happened to him. I can only hope Mr Stephensen successfully intervened.

Submitted by Molly at: July 1, 2012
I am so sick of children being treated as if they were born adults and are not responding to their devastating environments racked with poverty and hopelessness and constantly targeted. Cornell West's notion of nihilism is hard to argue with when you see these images and we have to be allies to people to stop this sense of hopelessness!

Submitted by Leslie at: June 30, 2012
Putting people who have not become adults in a prison for Life Without Release is wrong. A child or young person must be given the possibility to become literate, learn, develop a trade and have hope. Without hope, how would one live? However heinous their crime, we know their ability to make judgements and restrain impulses is limited.

Submitted by letpeacereign at: June 29, 2012
We have to do better than this. A child should not have to exist as this boy did prior to jail, and no one especially a child, deserves to be sent to such a hellacious place. We must change our lawa and mind-sets of those who send children to prison.

Submitted by Morgana at: June 29, 2012
I hope someday to be the kind of social worker who can stop this brutality and help to heal the victims of this system. I live in Pennsylvania where the Sandusky trial has just ended. Our society allows horrendous brutality in many forms against women, children, the elderly and the poor as well as men,but I am aware of history and have read Isabelle Allende's and Alice Walker's stories and I know that as long as we continue to live, there is hope. This story tears my heart out. Thank you for telling it. the international policies of the US Government are inextricably linked to the internal policies by their practice of victimizing human beings who are just trying to live thier lives as best they can.

Submitted by joneses at: June 29, 2012
We here in Alabama are aware of Mr. Stevenson's hard work. We encourage the continued work in the are of "juvenile" justice. We are hopeful that we will continue this challenge in the name of all children so that they may life a life of youthful fun and joy.

Submitted by bonpidge at: June 29, 2012
Very good. Children don't need to be sent to prison for LWOP, but they were in states like SD. Children obviously not fully responsible and the cradle to prison pipeline must be ended.

Submitted by Connie at: June 29, 2012
This makes my heart ache/sad and at the same time ANGRY!Why and how does this happen in the USA? thank you CDF for bringing this article to the public...thank you Bryan Stevenson for being bold & caring!

Submitted by Leslie at: June 29, 2012
This is an excellent decision. A child's mind is not as developed as that of an adult. Giving a young person the possibility of developing, learning, and possibly becoming a contributing member of society is important. Without education and other needed supports, some are unfortunately destined to end up in Prison.

Submitted by Scott at: June 29, 2012
Wow - Bryan is a man on a mission!